The Stripped Citizen
Humanity stripped of legal protection, reduced to mere biological survival on screen.
In cinema, this concept manifests when characters are stripped of their political and legal identities, leaving them as mere biological entities at the mercy of the state. These figures exist in a legal gray zone where they can be controlled, neglected, or destroyed without the usual protections of law or society. By focusing on these marginalized bodies, filmmakers expose the fragile boundary between being a recognized citizen and becoming mere 'bare life.'
Cinema has a haunting fascination with those who exist outside the law's warm embrace, reduced to mere biological survival. This state of bare life is most vividly realized in Children of Men (2006), where the Bexhill refugee camp serves as a literal cage for the stateless. Here, refugees are stripped of their humanity and rights, existing in a militarized zone where they can be caged or killed with total impunity, demonstrating how easily society can revoke the status of the protected citizen.
A different, more intimate form of this stripping occurs in Hunger (2008). Bobby Sands' deteriorating body becomes a political battleground; by refusing food, he reclaims the only thing the state has left him—his biological existence. His slow, systematic wasting away turns his own flesh into a weapon against a system that has stripped him of his political status, transforming bare life into a site of ultimate resistance.
In Dheepan (2015), the concept takes on a quieter, yet no less volatile, domestic shape. The refugee family in the French housing project occupies a legal and social vacuum, physically present but politically invisible, forced to navigate a violent criminal underworld while remaining entirely outside the protection of the state.
Even genre cinema wrestles with this boundary. In Train to Busan (2016), the infected populace is instantly stripped of all human rights by a panicked government. The quarantine measures reduce citizens to biological threats to be neutralized, showing how quickly the line between citizen and monster can be erased in the name of state security.
Finally, Lorna's Silence (2008) explores this vulnerability through the lens of immigration and intimacy. Lorna's phantom or real pregnancy represents a fragile, unrecognized life within a system of transactional citizenship, where both mother and unborn child are treated as mere commodities rather than human beings. Together, these films show that when the law retreats, the human body becomes the ultimate, vulnerable canvas.
Examples
Defining cases
- Children of Men (2006) — The Bexhill refugee camp
The Bexhill refugee camp exemplifies the concept of Homo Sacer. The camp is a space where refugees are reduced to 'bare life'—biologically alive but stripped of all political rights. They exist in a state of exception, where their lives can be taken by the state with impunity, highlighting a profound vulnerability and lack of legal protection within the sovereign order.
- Still Life (2013) — The legal and social status of the deceased individuals
The legal and social status of the deceased individuals in the film represents 'bare life,' individuals excluded from the social and symbolic order. Their existence is reduced to a mere biological fact that the state must hygienically manage. These unattended dead are modern examples of 'Homo Sacer,' lives that can be taken but not sacrificed, and John May's work attempts to reintegrate them into the community.
- Hunger (2008) — Bobby Sands' deteriorating body
Bobby Sands' deteriorating body is interpreted through the concept of *homo sacer*. Sands' body becomes a site where political life is stripped away, leaving only "bare life" that can be killed but not sacrificed. By willfully destroying this bare life through starvation, Sands reclaims a form of sovereign power over the very biological existence the state seeks to control, transforming a biopolitical subject into a political agent.
- Train to Busan (2016) — The infected populace and the government's quarantine measures
The infected populace and the government's quarantine measures serve as a political allegory for state failure, embodying Giorgio Agamben's concept of Homo Sacer. The zombies represent 'bare life' that can be exterminated without consequence, mirroring the dehumanization of citizens by an incompetent government. This potent critique echoes the Sewol Ferry disaster, highlighting the state's abandonment of its most vulnerable.
- Lorna's Silence (2008) — Lorna's initially fictional, later real or imagined, pregnancy
Lorna's initially fictional, later real or imagined, pregnancy positions the fetus as "bare life," a biological entity existing outside the legal and social order, akin to the concept of *homo sacer*. This status implies it can be willed out of existence without constituting homicide. Lorna's ultimate protection of this life becomes an ethical act that reclaims it from this precarious state.
Unexpected kin — far apart on the surface, family underneath
- Dheepan (2015) — The refugees' social and legal status within the Le Pré housing project.
The refugees' social and legal status within the Le Pré housing project reflects a precarious existence, akin to bare life. This status reveals a space where individuals are stripped of political rights and reduced to their biological existence, vulnerable to violence with impunity. The drug gangs and indifferent state create a zone of exception where Dheepan's life lacks legal protection, mirroring the statelessness of a refugee camp. This condition highlights the profound vulnerability and marginalization experienced by the family.